Cozy Suttons Bay Engagement | Nicole + Derek
Suttons Bay has always been a special place for Nicole and Derek, so it was only fitting that it played a big part in their engagement story. Their journey began way back in high school. Nicole barely remembers a moment when Derek showed some kindness at a Business Professionals of America Dance, while Derek vividly recalls seeing Nicole at the Snowball Dance just outside Suttons Bay Schools. But it wasn’t until Nicole’s junior prom that they truly connected—and we have Nicole’s grandma, Judy, and her brother Mikie to thank for that. With Nicole in desperate need of a last-minute date, Derek stepped up to the plate, and the rest, as they say, is history. Eight months later, their friendship had blossomed into something much more.
When it came time to pop the question, Derek left nothing to chance. He started the day with a coffee run (always a good move), followed by a scenic tour of their favorite spots, including the fishing docks, beaches, and the pier where they took their first prom photos. The proposal at the Suttons Bay marina pier almost got sidetracked by some overly enthusiastic U of M fans, but Derek pulled it off without a hitch. Nicole was completely caught off guard when Derek produced a ring from his jacket pocket—a moment she’ll never forget.
Nicole knew Derek was the one because of his rock-solid integrity. He was the guy who always showed up when he said he would, and he was honest—even when it wasn’t easy. That honesty built trust between them, and trust only grew stronger over time. Derek feels the same way about Nicole, believing that you choose love every day. For them, it’s the little things—both the big, memorable moments and the small, everyday ones—that make their relationship so strong and fun. The challenges they’ve faced together have deepened their love and respect for each other.
When they’re not making memories in Suttons Bay, Nicole and Derek enjoy visiting the zoo (especially the San Diego Zoo) and grabbing a bite at Olive Garden. Their engagement at Suttons Bay was filled with so many cherished memories, perfectly capturing the love and future they’re building together.
Ready to get your story documented? Reach out to us now to start planning!